How to Spend 5 Days in Puerto Rico: A San Juan Based Itinerary
*Disclosure: I only recommend products/services that I would use myself & all opinions expressed here are my own. This post may contain affiliate links meaning that, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission which in turn helps fund my next adventure! Please read the Privacy Policy for more information.
If you are dreaming of a Caribbean getaway that is easy to reach, packed with culture, and full of adventure, Puerto Rico is a perfect choice. It is one of my favorite islands to recommend because it is approachable, incredibly fun to explore, and ideal for the comfort-seeking traveler who wants a trip that feels special without feeling stressful. You can fly in, settle into a beautiful boutique stay, and start exploring right away.
When I visited San Juan for a week, I was surprised by how quickly I fell into a rhythm here. It was safe, walkable, and full of life, and it never felt overwhelming. I stayed at Casa Botanica near Condado Beach and walked around the area multiple times on my own at different times of day, and I never felt unsafe. It was one of the easiest and most enjoyable solo trips I have ever taken.
This five-day Puerto Rico itinerary is designed to help you experience the island’s highlights at a comfortable pace. You will explore Old San Juan, snorkel in crystal clear water near Icacos, discover the quieter west side of the island, kayak through Condado Lagoon, and enjoy a day inside El Yunque National Forest. It blends history, beaches, food, and adventure in a way that gives you a full sense of the island without overpacking your days.
If you want an easy-to-follow plan that fits into a long weekend or a quick escape, this Puerto Rico 5-day itinerary is the perfect place to start!
When to Visit Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico is a year-round destination, but some seasons offer a noticeably better experience depending on what you want from your trip.
The high season is December through April, the most popular time to visit. The weather is warm and dry, perfect for beach days and outdoor activities. Crowds are heavier in Old San Juan, and hotel prices rise, but the overall experience is still wonderful if you plan ahead.
If you prefer fewer crowds and better prices (like me), the shoulder seasons are ideal. Late April through early June and September through November tend to be more relaxed, and you can still enjoy great weather. These months are some of my favorite times to visit because you can explore at your own pace and enjoy a more local feel, especially around San Juan and the smaller towns. I visited during May both times I traveled to Puerto Rico and had perfect weather each time.
June through November overlaps with hurricane season, but most days are still sunny and warm. As long as you keep an eye on the weather, this can be a great time to visit if you want quieter beaches and more affordable hotel rates.
Where to Stay in San Juan, Puerto Rico
For this 5-day Puerto Rico itinerary, I recommend staying at Casa Botanica, one of the most unique and memorable boutique hotels in San Juan. This isn’t your typical place to stay. It is a converted house surrounded by lush greenery, tropical plants, and open-air spaces that make you feel tucked away in your own little jungle, even though you are just minutes from Condado Beach.
I stayed in the Vintage Treehouse Room, which genuinely feels like an island hideaway. The room is elevated, cozy, and full of charm, with an outdoor shower and a private balcony that I used every single day. Waking up to the sound of rustling palm trees and stepping straight outside felt like a dream. It is intentionally designed to make you feel close to nature without sacrificing comfort.
The room pictured here is one of the rooms on the ground floor. It was occupied during the majority of my stay, but I would pass it every day when I left, and I was obsessed with this room! Each guest room at Casa Botanica is unique in both design and layout.
Casa Botanica is a great fit for solo travelers, couples, and families with older kids who appreciate experiential, creative spaces. I would not recommend it for families with young children because the layout and room styles are more tailored toward adults. The vibe is peaceful, artistic, and warm, perfect for travelers wanting something more meaningful than a standard hotel room.
Another thing I loved is the location. You can walk to Condado Beach, explore nearby neighborhoods, or hop in a quick taxi to Old San Juan.
If you love unique stays that feel personal and thoughtful, Casa Botanica adds so much to your Puerto Rico experience. I honestly cannot recommend it enough!
5 Day Puerto Rico Itinerary
Day 1: Explore Old San Juan and Join a Food Tour
Start your trip in one of the most colorful and historic neighborhoods on the island. Old San Juan is filled with cobblestone streets, pastel buildings, cats lounging in hidden corners, and centuries of history around every turn. It is busiest at midday, but it becomes a little quieter and even more charming in the morning and early evening.
I recommend beginning with a stroll through the main squares and waterfront. You can explore at your own pace or join a guided walking tour that covers the essentials. After you have wandered and taken in the views of Castillo San Felipe del Morro, head over to San Cristobal or walk the Paseo de la Princesa for some shade and beautiful overlooks.
To really experience Old San Juan, you need to book a food tour. It is one of the easiest and most delicious ways to learn about Puerto Rican culture. You will sample dishes such as mofongo, empanadillas, fresh juices, and local desserts while hearing the history behind them. It is also a great way to get your bearings so you feel more confident exploring on your own later.
For dinner, try Deaverdura, which was hands down the best budget-friendly meal I had during my trip. I ate here for lunch and arrived right when they opened, and there was already a line around the corner. Everything is homemade, and the portions are generous. If you have extra time before sunset, walk along the city walls or stop for a cocktail in one of the bars like El Batey or Don Collins Coffee Cocktails.
Day 2: Day Trip to Puerto Rico’s West Coast
You can explore the west side on your own with a rental car, but if you prefer a stress-free option, I highly recommend joining a small group tour. I went on a group tour and had the best day! They can pick you up directly from your hotel in San Juan, and you’ll explore several spots that you would never have found on your own.
The first stop was Playa Guajataca in Isabela. The beach is stunning and has a bit of a rugged, wild feel. We walked through the historic tunnel, learned about the area’s history, and then followed a short trail along the cliffs. The views were incredible, and our guide shared fascinating details about the flora and fauna in the area.
Next, we headed to Crash Boat Beach in Aguadilla for swimming and free time. The water was crystal clear and at the perfect temperature. Crash Boat is lively but still relaxing, and you can easily spend hours here if time allowed. One of my favorite things about this stop was exploring the boat crash to the left of the piers and jumping off the pier into the water.
The final stop of the day was Faro Punta Higueras in Rincon for sunset. The lighthouse overlooks the ocean, and the light is golden and dreamy in the late afternoon. It was the perfect way to end the day. I would absolutely do this tour again and recommend it to anyone who wants to experience a completely different side of Puerto Rico without the hassle of navigating the island on their own. The exact tour I went on is no longer offered, but I’ve found a very similar one that covers the same region.
Day 3. Sail and Snorkel on an Icacos Catamaran Tour
Today is all about getting out on the water! If you want a relaxing adventure that still feels approachable, a catamaran tour to Icacos is the perfect choice. Icacos is a small uninhabited island off the coast of Fajardo, known for postcard-worthy turquoise water and some of the best snorkeling near San Juan.
I joined a mid-sized catamaran tour and had such a great experience. This boat tour departs at 9am and returns to the marina around 3pm. The crew was friendly from the moment I stepped on board, and the water conditions were calm all day. We sailed for about 45 minutes before anchoring off the shore of Icacos, where everyone could hop in and snorkel. The visibility was incredible, and the water was such a beautiful shade of blue-green. After exploring the first spot, we moved to a second area with a quieter reef filled with colorful fish.
Once the snorkeling portion wrapped up, the energy on board shifted into a more upbeat, social vibe. Music was playing, people were chatting with new friends, and everyone was in that blissful post-snorkeling mood.
This tour is ideal for anyone who loves the water. It is also a great fit for anyone who wants a tropical experience without anything too intense or strenuous. Bring reef-safe sunscreen, a towel, a waterproof phone pouch, and enjoy one of the best water experiences just a short drive from San Juan. If you don’t plan on renting a car while you’re visiting Puerto Rico, you’re in luck. This tour offers a ticket option that includes round-trip transportation from your San Juan hotel. Keep in mind that your morning will start a little earlier, but it’s worth it not to have to deal with driving in an unfamiliar place.
Day 4: Kayak in San Juan and Relax at Condado Beach
Ease into the morning with a unique experience right in San Juan. I booked a glass-bottom kayak tour for the morning of my last day in Puerto Rico, and it was such a nice way to start the day.
Your tour takes place on Condado Lagoon, a calm, protected body of water that is perfect for beginners or anyone who just wants an easy, scenic paddle. Sessions are offered daily from 9am to 4pm on the hour, and the whole activity lasts about one hour. It is short enough not to take up your entire day, yet long enough to feel refreshed and energized afterward.
The kayaks are clear-bottom, which I always appreciate in tropical destinations because you can see everything below you. Our guide was friendly, informative, and patient with the handful of first-timers in our group. It had the perfect balance of fun facts, gentle paddling, and those quiet moments when you can just take in the scenery.
After your tour, head over to Condado Beach for a slow afternoon in the sun. This beach is walkable from the lagoon and from Casa Botanica. It is one of the most popular beaches in the area, but it is still easy to find a comfortable spot. Bring a book, rent a lounger, grab a smoothie or coffee from a nearby cafe, and enjoy a few hours of salt air and sunshine.
If you want to elevate the day a bit, consider booking a beachfront cabana through ResortPass, the best travel hack for beach-lovers. If you haven’t used Resort Pass before, you essentially browse the options in the area and rent a cabana or purchase a day-pass to use the resort's facilities for a fraction of the price you would pay if you booked a room there. Some fantastic options near Condado Beach include: The Condado Plaza Hotel, Condado Ocean Club (adults-only), and AC Hotel.
Day 5. Explore El Yunque National Forest
Even if you only have five days in Puerto Rico, I still recommend carving out time to visit El Yunque National Forest. It is the only tropical rainforest in the U.S. National Forest system. While it is more touristy than the other experiences in this itinerary, it is genuinely beautiful and worth seeing at least once.
The easiest way to visit is to join a guided tour, which eliminates the hassle of timed-entry reservations and navigating the winding mountain roads. Tours typically include round-trip transportation from San Juan, a guided hike to waterfalls and natural pools, and time to swim or relax in the water. Most tours last 4 to 5 hours, making it a great half-day adventure that still leaves room for a relaxed final evening in San Juan. The first time I visited San Juan, we went on a ziplining adventure through the rainforest. While it was thrilling, I wish we had done something more meaningful that actually let us experience the rainforest.
If you prefer to explore on your own and you have a rental car, you can book a timed entry slot through Recreation.gov and drive into the park yourself. Just keep in mind that parking is limited and the most popular trails can get busy by mid-morning. Going early helps a lot!
Whether you join a tour or do your own thing, expect lush jungle scenery, river views, and refreshing mountain air. Bring sturdy shoes, plenty of water, and be prepared to get a little muddy if it has rained recently.
After your El Yunque adventure, head back to San Juan for a leisurely final night. Treat yourself to dinner at Cocina Abierta or wander into Old San Juan for one last stroll through the cobblestone streets.
If You Have 7 Days in Puerto Rico
If you have a whole week in Puerto Rico, you can easily extend this itinerary and experience even more of what makes the island special. With two extra days, I recommend heading toward the East Coast, where the pace slows down, and the beaches feel even more local and low-key.
Stay a Night or Two in Fajardo
Fajardo is about an hour from San Juan and makes the perfect base for exploring Puerto Rico’s smaller islands. It has a totally different vibe from the city and offers easier access to some of the region's prettiest water.
From Fajardo, you can:
Take a ferry or small boat to Vieques - Known for wild horses, uncrowded beaches, and the world-famous Mosquito Bay. It is one of the most magical bioluminescent experiences on Earth.
Visit Culebra for Flamenco Beach - Flamenco routinely ranks as one of the top beaches in the world, and for good reason. Powder-soft sand, clear turquoise water, and a laid-back atmosphere make it a must-see for beach lovers.
Go sailing or snorkeling - Many tours depart from Fajardo and visit quiet coves and reefs you would never find on your own.
If you want a trip that blends adventure with relaxation, spending a couple of days out here makes the experience feel more balanced and immersive.
How to Get Around Puerto Rico
Getting around Puerto Rico is much easier than most first-time visitors expect, and your transportation plan really depends on how much of the island you want to see.
Rental Car - If you plan to explore beyond San Juan, even for just one or two days, renting a car is the most convenient choice. Major rental companies operate at the San Juan airport, and the drives to places like El Yunque, Fajardo, and the west coast are straightforward. Roads are generally well-maintained, and navigation is simple with Google Maps. Parking can be tight in Old San Juan, so I recommend leaving your car at home for day trips and walking or ridesharing while in the city.
Rideshare and Taxis - Within San Juan, Uber is reliable and affordable. This is what I used most often when getting to and from Old San Juan, Condado Beach, and restaurant hopping at night. Taxis are also available, especially around the airport and major hotels.
Small Group Tours - For certain activities, I recommend joining a small group tour instead of driving. For example, the west side of the island is a long day of exploring, and it felt amazing not having to worry about driving or parking. The same goes for catamaran tours, El Yunque excursions, and kayak tours. Most include round-trip transportation from San Juan, so you can simply enjoy the day. Joining a group tour is one of the best ways to avoid renting a car, plus you usually get inside knowledge from the local who’s leading the tour and skip-the-line access.
Walking Within San Juan - San Juan is more walkable than people expect. I walked around Condado Beach several times at different hours of the day and always felt comfortable. Old San Juan is extremely walkable and, for the most part, flat. For anything too far or too hot to walk, Uber fills in the gaps perfectly.
Overall, you do not need a car for your full five days in Puerto Rico unless you prefer total independence. A mix of ridesharing, walking, and small-group tours works beautifully for most travelers.
Why You Need to Explore Beyond San Juan
San Juan is an incredible home base. It is colorful, historic, culturally rich, and perfect for first-time visitors. But Puerto Rico has so much more to offer once you step outside the city limits. If you only stay in San Juan, you miss the island’s quieter beaches, small towns, tropical forests, and the kind of experiences that make a trip feel more meaningful. Exploring beyond San Juan gives you:
A deeper connection to the island - Places like Rincón, Isabela, and Fajardo show a more relaxed, local side of Puerto Rico.
More variety in scenery and activities - One day you are snorkeling at Icacos, the next you are walking through a rainforest or watching a sunset over the surf.
A break from the crowds - Venturing west or east is perfect for travelers who want a bit more calm without sacrificing convenience.
Unique memories you simply will not get in the city - Things like walking through coastal tunnels, snorkeling vibrant reefs, and kayaking in a lagoon feel worlds away but are still easy day trips.
San Juan is the heart of the island, but exploring beyond it is where the magic really opens up! The first time I visited Puerto Rico, we stayed at an all-inclusive resort near San Juan, and it was great, but I didn’t get to experience much of what the island has to offer. For my second trip, I knew I wanted to stay somewhere centrally located, but I also wanted to get outside of San Juan and explore as much as possible, and now I can’t wait to go back and explore even more!
Now that you have a complete 5-day Puerto Rico itinerary plus ideas for extending your trip, you can start planning a vacation that fits your travel style and energy level. Whether you want to wander Old San Juan, snorkel turquoise water, hike to waterfalls, or relax on quiet beaches, Puerto Rico makes it incredibly easy to do it all in one trip.
If you are still deciding what to do on your trip, you might find it helpful to dive deeper into a few of the experiences from this itinerary. My Old San Juan guide breaks down the best things to see and eat in the historic district, and my review of Casa Botanica gives you a closer look at the unique boutique stay that became my home base. If the catamaran day is the part you are most excited for, my dedicated Icacos boat tour review walks you through exactly what to expect. And if you are curious about seeing more of the island, my review of the West Coast small-group tour explains why that day ended up being one of my favorite memories of the entire trip.
No matter how you shape your itinerary, Puerto Rico is an amazing destination with tons more to see than the main hot spots. And if you want help customizing this trip to your travel style, I am always happy to help you build something personal and stress-free through my custom trip planning service.
Happy travels!
-Tess
Looking for more Caribbean travel inspiration? Check out these articles!
Tess Arnold
Hi! I’m Tess, founder of TravelingTessie.com, and not only do I love to travel, but I love immersing myself in new places and finding off the beaten path experiences wherever I go! I’ve lived in 4 different states & traveled to 13 countries and counting. I believe that tourism is meant to benefit both visitors and locals alike—and I want to bring that idea back into the travel industry by highlighting companies run by locals such as tours, hotels, restaurants, and more. On Traveling Tessie you can find hidden gems in top destinations around the world, travel tips, detailed city guides, and tons of inspiration for your next trip! If you love travel as much as I do, then please join me on this journey! I hope you enjoy my content as much as I enjoy providing it for you!